Each AFL club’s biggest ‘What If’ player of the last 25 years

Who has been each AFL club’s biggest ‘What If’ player of the last 25 years?

On SEN Mornings, Julian De Stoop has been running the ‘Club Calibration’ segment which asks various footy questions to see how in sync each fanbase is.

First up was finding out the best win for each of the 18 clubs since the year 2000. Then we had the most traumatic loss.

We also took a look at the best individual player and most underrated player, and the best decision and worst decision made by each club.

We took you through each club’s ‘What If’ moment and now it is time for the ‘What If’ player.

The below responses came through most frequently from SEN listeners.

Each AFL club’s biggest ‘What If’ player of the last 25 years

Adelaide: Trent Hentschel

Brisbane: Jared Brennan

Carlton: Caleb Marchbank

Collingwood: Sean Rusling

Essendon: Scott Gumbleton

Fremantle: Cam McCarthy

Geelong: Dan Menzel

Gold Coast: Harley Bennell

GWS Giants: Jonathan Patton

Hawthorn: Max Bailey

Melbourne: Liam Jurrah

North Melbourne: Jesse Smith

Port Adelaide: John Butcher

Richmond: Mark Coughlan

St Kilda: Spencer White

Sydney: Sam Reid

West Coast: Ashley Sampi

Western Bulldogs: Shaun Higgins